Seth Donnelly

Personal

The Long Game Cut Its Thursday Hours

December 4, 2025 · Seth Donnelly

There’s a sign taped to the door now, handwritten, new hours starting this month, and the shop closes at seven instead of nine on weekdays. I noticed it on a Thursday, which is exactly the wrong day to notice it, since Thursday used to be my regular after-work stop before heading to Mara’s for game night. Seven doesn’t work for that anymore, not with my actual schedule, and I’ve been surprised by how much that small change has been sitting with me since.

It’s a small business, the kind of place that survives on a mix of regulars and foot traffic, and I don’t know the specifics of why the hours changed, staffing probably, rent probably, the usual list of reasons a small shop’s math stops working the way it used to. What I do know is that I’d built a whole little ritual around that Thursday stop without ever really noticing I’d built it, browse for twenty minutes, usually walk out with nothing, occasionally walk out with something I hadn’t planned on, then head to game night already halfway into the right headspace for it. Even the smell of the place did some of that work, cardboard and shrink wrap and whatever candle they keep burning near the register, and I didn’t clock how much that mattered until I started thinking about losing it.

I could just shift the errand to a weekend, obviously, that’s the practical fix and I’ll probably end up doing it. But there was something specific about that Thursday version of the routine, low stakes, no real intention to buy anything, just a place to be for twenty minutes between one part of the week and the next. Weekend errands come with their own momentum, a list, a plan, other stops to make. I don’t think I’ll get the aimless version back just by moving the same activity to a different day.

I asked the guy behind the counter about it, half expecting a vague answer, and he was actually pretty candid, said online sales for the shop have basically stayed flat for two years while foot traffic quietly dropped, and cutting hours was cheaper than cutting the part-time staff further than they already had. He said it without much drama in his voice, like he’d already explained it to enough regulars that the explanation had worn smooth, and I got the sense I wasn’t the first person to stand at that counter looking more upset about it than the situation probably called for. I don’t have any real leverage over that as one customer who buys sleeves and the occasional board game, but I’ve started being more deliberate about buying things there instead of ordering the same item online for a couple dollars less, which is a small, mostly symbolic gesture that I know won’t fix a shop’s underlying math by itself.

I bought a pack of sleeves I didn’t need on my way out, mostly so the visit wouldn’t feel wasted. Small gesture, I know. Felt like the least I could do for a shop that’s clearly having a harder year than it used to.

#personal 522 words